Investing vs paying off debt: which should come first?

When we’re helping our clients with their financial planning, they often ask us whether they should prioritise paying off debts or focus on saving and investing. In this article, our team of experienced independent financial advisers at PIL Southampton walks you through points to consider.

 

Your financial priorities

Managing your finances is always a balance between the needs and obligations you have today and the financial commitments you’re likely to have in the future. 

As you go through different life stages, so your financial priorities will shift. At various points, you are likely to be saving for your first home, providing for your family and finding the funds to pay for childcare or for one of you to work less to help with the juggle. As time moves on, you might want to help put children through university, contribute towards a wedding, or help them buy their first home.

Before you know it, it’ll be time to retire and, the earlier you start planning and investing for retirement, the greater the opportunity you may have to build retirement savings.

And, of course, there’s holidays and cars, renovations and repairs and whatever unknown life circumstances may come our way like injury or illness affecting income. 

All these events and demands have an impact on your finances.

 

When to prioritise paying off debt

For most people, the first priority should be to pay off any expensive debts, like higher rate credit card bills and store cards.

If you’re paying more interest on debt than you’d be earning in interest on savings, then it makes sense to pay these debts off before you start building a nest egg.

Don’t rush to pay everything off as quickly as you can, though, if it could leave you short – without enough of a financial cushion if you have any unexpected expenditure.

 

Types of debt to focus on

Look at any debts you have that have the most serious consequences if you don’t pay them – for example, court fines, penalty notices, council tax, and child maintenance. 

Then, use your statements to check interest rates on any credit agreements. This will enable you to prioritise the highest rate debts so you can pay them off first. 

If you have a mortgage, it’s a debt that could help to provide for your future if you’re building equity in the property but, as a secured loan, it also means that you could lose your home if you don’t keep up your repayments.

You might find that using a credit card for an unexpected expense like a replacement boiler is the only way to quickly come up with the funds you need but make sure you prioritise paying the credit card bill as soon as you can, ideally by the due date after the spend occurs to avoid paying high interest.

 

How to work out which are your most expensive debts

Your most expensive debts are generally those with the highest interest rates, rather than the biggest amount you owe. 

Store cards, credit cards, ‘buy now pay later’ loans and short-term loans generally have the highest interest rates as they are all unsecured. So, focus on paying them back first. It’s important to at least pay the minimum monthly amount as not doing so will have a negative impact on your credit rating.

You’ll improve your financial situation by paying more than the minimum repayment whenever you can, though.

If you get a bonus, inheritance, or other windfall, and can pay off your debts, first check that you won’t incur any early repayment penalties. This is particularly relevant for your mortgage agreement. 

 

Building an emergency savings fund

It’s financially prudent to have an instant access savings fund for unforeseen expenses, like needing to replace a broken washing machine.

In an ideal world, your emergency savings fund should be enough to cover three to six months of your bills and all the expenses you need to live day to day. If that’s too much to be a realistic goal, then save what you can. 

Consistently saving every month, however little, is a good habit to start and keep up.

 

When it makes sense to start investing

When you’ve built up a substantial savings balance, you might want to consider investing some of your savings to make your money work harder for you. 

Cash ISAs are a tax-efficient way of saving. Interest is paid tax-free, and rates can sometimes be higher than those available on standard savings accounts, although this is not always the case.

Pension contributions are also a tax-efficient way of investing for your longer-term future.

If you want the potential of increasing your capital through investments, the general rule of thumb is the higher the reward, the higher the risk. The value of your investments may go down as well as up, and your capital is not guaranteed.

 

Should you pay off your mortgage with savings?

Just like with any decision between paying off a loan or saving money, the key factor is the interest rate – if your mortgage rate is higher than the amount you would be earning in interest, then overpaying your mortgage may be worth considering rather than put any extra money you’ve got in savings.

And, because your mortgage is a very long-term loan, usually 25 years, that’s a lot of interest over the years so reducing your mortgage balance can reduce the amount of interest paid over the life of the mortgage, although whether it is the most suitable option will depend on your wider financial circumstances.

Make sure, though, that you don’t exceed the overpayment limit stipulated in your mortgage’s terms and conditions, which could incur an early repayment charge.

 

Pay off the most expensive debts first

Your aim is to minimise the amount of interest you have to pay on your debts so, to reiterate the point we’ve made earlier in this article, check what interest rate you’re paying on each of your debts and focus on paying back the highest interest rate debts first.

And, as we mentioned before, remember to also prioritise the debts that have the most serious consequences if you default on them.

 

Mistakes to avoid

Don’t neglect high interest and priority debts – pay these back first, and before you put money aside in savings and investments.

Don’t leave yourself without an emergency fund.

Don’t pay more than you need to in fees – do your research before you take out a loan or sign up for a particular investment.

Consider making pension contributions where affordable so that you can benefit from available tax relief and support your retirement planning.

 

How PIL Southampton can help you 

Our experienced, friendly team of financial advisers can help you to manage your financial arrangements efficiently and effectively. We will take the time to get to know you, your circumstances, and your financial goals so that, together, we can make a plan that makes your money work best for you.

 

How you can contact PIL Southampton

You can email us, fill out the contact form on our website or call us on 02380 668407. We look forward to hearing from you.